A Suggestion for iTunes Genius...and how I work around it until they implement my suggestion.
I Still love making mixtapes. Ofcourse they are not really tapes anymore. Most of us burn our mixes on CD-Rs. However, just like how some audiophiles still call an album or song on any format a record, I still call my homemade, self-sequenced CD-R compilations mixtapes.
I love the generous feeling of intimacy by giving a mix to a friend. I still haven't been able to establish that same feeling designing a playlist online with a URL to pass along to someone. Maybe within time, but not now. I will try it out someday in the near future, but jeez unless Myspace For Mobile allows playlist streaming, how are my friends going to listen to their Myspace playlist I create for them outside of their computers? (For a rant about Myspace Playlists, see my post from last October)
I have been critical about iTunes Genius in the past and feel it is still inferior to both Last.fm and Pandora as far as music recommendation apps go. However, admittedly, I use Genius almost daily. I use it to quickly build playlists to load onto my iPod. I use it nighttime playlists that use to fall asleep to. Genius offers a choice on how big you want that playlist to be (25, 50, 75, or 100 songs). I think it would be a great addition if Apple included a 5th selection: "CD". What this selection would do is build a playlist based on time (72 or 80 minutes) and not by the number of tracks. From there you can right click the playlist name from the left playlist column and select "Burn Playlist To Disc" for a quick mix-CD on the go. Why engineers at Apple didn't think of this before is debatable. Although iTunes does have a CD burning function, their decision to not associate the playlist building of their Genius application with CD burning may have something more to do with their obvious motive to help customers enjoy their iPods more and their CDs less.
And perhaps their is market research on their part that suggests that many people don't use iTunes to burn CDs.
So, in my desperate attempt to replicate my iTunes wish, I came up with a step-by-step process that I use to burn new mixtapes. It's not exactly "on-the-go", especially considering my history of trivial indecisiveness. But I was pleased with the results nonetheless.
- Pick a song and click the Genius playlist button (it looks like a flower, but look closer and it's either an atom or molecule). Set the "limit to" playlist count to 100 (if 100 songs is too much to sift through, then go ahead and pick a lower number).
- Rather than clicking "Save Playlist", create a new playlist and name it after the base song. Use the word "genius" and feel free to get cute (see my examples below).
- Drag and drop the songs in the Genius playlist to the newly named playlist.
- Now, time to choose songs from the 100 that Genius selected. On the very bottom of he iTunes window is the total time length of the playlist. The key is to get the time below 1 hours & 20 minutes. Here are some rules I applied when choosing songs to keep or delete. a. Only one song per artist. This will actually cut the song cut in half and bring the 80 minute goal closer. b. Choose songs that do not exist in any previous mix-CD or pre-recorded CD. c. Feel free to replace songs in case Genius chose a alternate version. I did this for the Follow The Genius mix. Genius chose a the slower-then-faster version of 45 Grave's "Partytime" while I preferred the more famous version that appeared on the Return Of The Living Dead soundtrack (the one which lyrics reflect partying teens facing their impending doom, not the one with lyrics that speak of a young girl raped and abused). So I just deleted the version I disliked and dropped in the version I did. I would had done this for "Mr. Jones" by Psychedelic Furs from the same mix. I let the original version that appeared on their first greatest hits album rather than the preferred version that appears on their Talk Talk Talk album.
- Once the playlist has been sorted and deleted enough to be under 80 minutes, then the playlist can be re-sorted with the base song on top and burned to CD.
Here are my first two mixtapes I made with iTunes Genius. The first is based on The National's "Mistaken For Strangers" titled Mistaken For A Genius Mix. I like this mix because it helped me get alot of the various indie rock singles on my hard drive on a CD while also choosing some one-hit wonders from the early years of modern rock (Happy Mondays, Charlatans). The second is based on Killing Joke's "Follow The Leaders" titled Follow The Genius. This mix seemed to capture alot of various goth/post-punk songs, yet it's interesting that Genius chose songs from the most recent Bauhaus and Damned albums and even selected something from the glam/proto-punk era ("Amateur Hour" by Sparks).
Below are my complete mixes published (song and artist)
MISTAKEN FOR A GENIUS MIX CD
1. "Mistaken For Strangers" by The National
2. "The Only One I Know" by The Charlatans
3. "An Honest Mistake" by The Bravery
4. "Step On" by The Happy Mondays
5. "Spread Your Love" by Black Rebel Motorcycle Club
6. "Keep Your Eyes Ahead" by The Helio Sequence
7. "Tonight I Have To Leave It" by The Shout Out Louds
8. "Reason Is Treason" by Kasabian
9. "Blood" by The Editors
10. "Hunting For Witches" by Bloc Party
11. "Must Be The Moon" by !!!
12. "Battle For The Sun" by Placebo
13. "Standing In The Way Of Control" by The Gossip
14. "Here's Your Future" by The Thermals
15. "It's A Hit" by We Are Scientists
16. "Between Us & Them" by Moving Units
17. "Hold On, Hold On" by Neko Case
18. "Morning Light" by Gliss
19. "I'm Confused" by Handsome Furs
20. "Slow Hands" by Interpol
15. "It's A Hit" by We Are Scientists
16. "Between Us & Them" by Moving Units
17. "Hold On, Hold On" by Neko Case
18. "Morning Light" by Gliss
19. "I'm Confused" by Handsome Furs
20. "Slow Hands" by Interpol
FOLLOW THE GENIUS MIX CD
1. "Follow the Leaders" by Killing Joke
2, "Amateur Hour" by Sparks
3. "Partytime" by 45 Grave
4. "Little Miss Disaster" by The Damned
5. "To Hell With Poverty" by Gang Of Four
2, "Amateur Hour" by Sparks
3. "Partytime" by 45 Grave
4. "Little Miss Disaster" by The Damned
5. "To Hell With Poverty" by Gang Of Four
6. "Adrenalin" by Bauhaus
7. "Glass" by Joy Division
8. "The Back of Love" by Echo & The Bunnymen
9. "Stargazer" by Siouxsie & The Banshees
10. "Hollow Eyes" by Red Lorry Yellow Lorry
11. "Kiss Kiss (Bang Bang)" by Specimen
12. "Into The Valley" by The Skids
13. "Mr. Jones" by Psychedelic Furs
14. "Dance with Me" by Lords Of The New Church
15. "Primary" by The Cure
16. "Careering" by Public Image Limited
17. "Spiritwalker" by The Cult
18. "Nightmares" by Flock of Seagulls
19. "Cruisers Creek" by The Fall
20. "Release The Bats" by The Birthday Party
For more on iTunes Genius, please read Let's Get Genius and Not So Genius
| Share on Facebook |


Comments