Did Ned's Atomic Dustbin "inspire" the sound of Face to Face and other melodic hardcore bands of the early 90s?

Silly theory, I know. Southern California melodic hardcore band Face to Face formed in 1991 and released their debut album Don't Turn Away (which features the first and best version of "Disconnected") on Dr. Strange in 1992. Other bands from the western states of this particular sub-genre like Monsula and Horace Pinker pre-date Face to Face by a year or two. 

Ned's Atomic Dustin was formed in England during the late 80s and released their debut album Bite in 1990 while touring with The Wonder Stuff. The video for my prime example and their first successful U.S. single "Happy" was released in 1991 (from the God Fodder album). It's hard to make a case due to visual obstacles. Ned's, as well as many other bands from the short lived "Grebo Rock" scene, exhibited a style that looked like it was borrowed from Faith No More (baggy clothes, sneakers, long hair - sometimes in dreads, other times shaved on one side, the use of warm and flourescent colors). However, watch the video for "Happy". To block out the band visually, close your eyes and just listen. Hear the melodic bassline intro. The guitar joins in right before the break-out that joins the drums and jump starts the first verse ( I can't think of how many punk songs from the mid-90s use the same general arrangement , especially the tempo change). Block out the brit-pop vocals. Notice the melodic interlude that happens between the verses, with the bass resuming the lead melody and the two stringed octaved power chords complimenting the bass with its own alternate melody. Sound familar?



Either Ned's Atomic Dustbin tuned into the exploding SoCal and NoCal punk scenes that gave birth to this style of melodic rock at an early stage before the rest of the world, or there were alot of bands in the west coast that heard Ned's on the radio/MTV and borrowed some of their song structures and bass/guitar arrangements, sped up the tempo, while adding different vocals to make it sound less English and more SoCal.

Some will argue that it was the style implemented by older SoCal bands like D.I., Bad Religion, and Adolescents that inspired what exploded from that same geographic five to ten years later (I mean Rikk Agnew invited the minus-5th power chord, right?), but I think it's just far too coincidental that, even though N.A.D. were familair with the older more popular melodic punk rock bands, that they were able to intrepet that influence into a similar sound halfway across the globe without yet hearing what bands like Face to Face would record and release years later.


  
    
  Share on Facebook



 

What did you think of this article?




Trackbacks
  • No trackbacks exist for this post.
Comments
  • No comments exist for this post.
Leave a comment

Submitted comments are subject to moderation before being displayed.

 Name

 Email (will not be published)

 Website

Your comment is 0 characters limited to 3000 characters.